Gérald Darmanin has asked the Superior Council of the Judiciary to rule on the conduct of a magistrate in Auch in the Lyhanna affair.
The Minister of the Interior, Gérald Darmanin, has decided to refer the handling of the Lyhanna affair by a magistrate at the Auch court to the Superior Council of the Judiciary (CSM). This exceptional move comes amid intense tensions between the executive and the judicial branch.
According to reports, the minister is contesting the way this magistrate handled the Lyhanna case. Without going into the procedural details of the ongoing investigation, this referral raises questions about the independence of the justice system and the CSM's prerogatives regarding the oversight of magistrates.
This affair is not without recalling other precedents where government members deemed it necessary to approach the Superior Council of the Judiciary. These interventions are generally poorly received by judicial bodies, which see them as an attempt to influence the functioning of justice.
At the Auch court, it is indicated that the magistrate concerned continues to carry out her duties while awaiting the CSM's decision. The judicial institution recalls that procedures are governed by strict rules guaranteeing respect for the adversarial principle and the rights of the defense.
This referral could have significant political repercussions, as relations between the Ministry of the Interior and the judicial world are already fragile due to several sensitive cases in recent months.
According to reports, the minister is contesting the way this magistrate handled the Lyhanna case. Without going into the procedural details of the ongoing investigation, this referral raises questions about the independence of the justice system and the CSM's prerogatives regarding the oversight of magistrates.
This affair is not without recalling other precedents where government members deemed it necessary to approach the Superior Council of the Judiciary. These interventions are generally poorly received by judicial bodies, which see them as an attempt to influence the functioning of justice.
At the Auch court, it is indicated that the magistrate concerned continues to carry out her duties while awaiting the CSM's decision. The judicial institution recalls that procedures are governed by strict rules guaranteeing respect for the adversarial principle and the rights of the defense.
This referral could have significant political repercussions, as relations between the Ministry of the Interior and the judicial world are already fragile due to several sensitive cases in recent months.
Advertisement
Source: La Nouvelle République